Early Contractor Involvement (ECI)

sustainability in construction
Sustainable Construction: Building for a Better Future
2 March, 2023
sustainable design principles
Sustainable Design Principles
8 May, 2023

Early Contractor Involvement (ECI) is a well-known term in the construction industry and among quantity surveyors. Let’s explore its importance, meaning and benefits for construction projects and contract parties in this blog post.

What is Early Contractor Involvement?

ECI is a construction contracting method that enables a builder to become involved in the work on a construction project before the project design has been completed. Since the total project cost is not yet known at this stage because the design has not been finalised, the contractor provides insights and predictions regarding overheads, preliminaries, potential profits, and time frames of the project.

The Early Contractor Involvement process involves sharing responsibilities between a contractor and a designer. Contractors can provide valuable suggestions and input about major design and construction decisions, which can have a positive impact on the quality of the project.

ECI is well-suited for complex projects, and its methods can significantly decrease the construction project’s risk by conducting design reviews that analyse buildability, value engineering, and material delivery.

What are the benefits of Early Contractor Involvement?

ECI allows contractors to suggest potential modifications in the design of the building, which increases the project’s flexibility compared to traditional procurement methods. Studies have shown that ECI can contribute to a cost savings of 7% in total and a time savings of 10% during the actual construction phase.

Therefore, the main benefits of Early Contractor Involvement include:

  • Reduced project costs
  • Better time management of projects
  • Increased transparency over subcontractor pricing
  • Improved project quality by obtaining the builder’s input regarding major design components.

How does Early Contractor Involvement work?

The Early Contractor Involvement process can be divided into two phases: a planning phase (pre-construction phase) and a construction phase.

The pre-construction phase is where the contractor’s inputs are utilised to achieve better time, cost, and quality standards for the project. During this phase, the contractor is engaged in providing final predictions regarding the scope and cost of the project, as well as giving design feedback. Additionally, this phase often involves identifying and mitigating project risks and finalising work on contracts that will begin in phase two.

The second phase, which is the construction phase, involves carrying out the actual construction work based on the findings and agreements completed during the previous phase.

The value of ECI in building procurement

The ECI model has proven to be highly effective in securing supplies and resources in the volatile market conditions of today. Given the high risk, price volatility, and material shortages characteristic of the supply chain, ECI can mitigate these issues by establishing relationships with contractors early on and forming strategic partnerships.

What are the forms of ECI contracts?

There are three forms of ECI contracts in total:

  1. Construction Management (CM) – In this type of ECI, the construction manager oversees the construction project on behalf of the principal and provides preliminaries. The principal hires trade contractors based on the manager’s recommendations, and the construction manager is paid a fee for their work, while the principal holds responsibility for trade contractors.
  2. Managing Contractor (MC) – Trade contractors are hired by the construction manager, who is responsible to the principal for the contractors’ actions, omissions, and performance. In this type of ECI, the construction manager is compensated either with a fee plus third-party costs for the construction work or with a lump sum price based on an accurate estimation of the total cost of the contractor’s work.
  3. Guaranteed Maximum Price (GMP) – In this scenario, construction managers hire trade contractors who are responsible for their work and must operate within a fixed budget without exceeding it, which needs to be sufficient for all construction costs.

What is the difference between Early Contractor Involvement and traditional procurement?

The primary distinction between traditional procurement and ECI is that, in traditional procurement, the contractor is hired after the project’s design has been finalised and accepted by the project owners. Contractors that will perform the construction work are chosen based on their proposals after the invitation to tender is issued, and principals generally prefer to consider offers from as many qualified and professional contractors as possible.

In contrast, ECI involves selecting a single contractor in the project’s early stages and compensating them on the scheme. The contractor can then influence the project to suggest design changes that can add value to the finished building and enhance the quality of the output.

What are some examples of Early Contractor Involvement (ECI)?

There are several examples of ECI in the construction industry, including:

  • Design-build: The project owner contracts with a single contractor to provide both design and construction services.
  • Construction management-at-risk (CMAR): The project owner contracts with a construction manager who provides pre-construction services such as cost estimating, defining time frames, and value engineering, as well as construction services.
  • Integrated project delivery (IPD): The project owner, contractor, and designer collaborate from the initial phase of the project to develop a design that meets the owner’s objectives.
  • Public-private partnerships (PPP): A collaboration between the public and private sectors on infrastructure projects.
  • Early Contractor Involvement in pre-construction: This involves hiring contractors before the design phase begins.

Is ECI popular in the Australian construction industry?

The Australian construction industry has adopted the ECI approach, which was initially introduced by the Queensland Department of Main Roads (DMR) in 2005. Although it is categorised as ECI, it is an innovative approach that is different from any previously used contract types, particularly in the road construction industry.

Since ECI has demonstrated a multitude of benefits for managing construction projects in Australia, it is becoming increasingly popular for such projects across the country.

What are some challenges of Early Contractor Involvement?

While ECI can offer many benefits, there are also some challenges that may arise during its implementation. Here are some common challenges:

  • Choosing the right contractor: Since there are plenty of qualified contractors on the market, it can be challenging to find the right one for your project. This issue becomes even more challenging for large-scale projects.
  • Managing stakeholders’ expectations: Sometimes, stakeholders can have conflicting interests, making it difficult to balance them.
  • Communication issues: Communication issues become more prominent as the number of stakeholders and partners in a project increases.
  • Managing project risks: It’s difficult to detect potential project risks early on.
  • Managing budget control: Unexpected costs can arise, making it difficult to stick to the budget.

What are some best practices for Early Contractor Involvement?

To achieve the maximum benefits of Early Contractor Involvement (ECI) and mitigate its potential challenges, here are some best practices to follow:

  1. Foster collaboration: Collaboration among all partners in the project can create trust and open communication, leading to greater benefits for all parties.
  2. Establish clear project objectives: All parties must work towards the same goal, and setting clear project objectives can help ensure everyone is aligned.
  3. Maintain proper and timely communication: Keeping everyone informed about the project, progress, risks, and cost is crucial for the project’s success.
  4. Engage a contractor early on: Contractors can add value to the project by suggesting design changes that enhance the final building’s quality.
  5. Maintain transparent cost projections: Contractors should provide clear and transparent information about the cost projections, helping to manage the budget and avoid unexpected costs.
  6. Identify and mitigate project risks early: Early detection of potential project risks can reduce delays and other issues down the line.

Seeking Expert ECI Assistance?

If you’re considering implementing Early Contractor Involvement (ECI) in your procurement process, it’s a good idea to consult with a registered and professional quantity surveyor. They can provide valuable guidance on the best approach to take.

At PBAQs, we have over 20 years of experience helping clients choose the best procurement strategy for their construction projects. We can help you identify the most suitable procurement approach for your project and guide you through the implementation process.

Schedule a consultation now to discover expert guidance on ECI and other powerful procurement strategies. Let our dedicated team propel your project towards unprecedented success. Book a consultation with us today.

Angelo Antidormi
Latest posts by Angelo Antidormi (see all)